Homeschool vs. Regular Schooling
Maizie is hyper as all get out tonight. She knows we begin homeschooling tomorrow. Even though we keep a very loose schedule Maizie seems excited and nervous. At the same time her attitude is not the greatest. However, she did insist on going to bed with a pile of worksheets to complete. Maizie is very into learning on her own. Most of the time I feel like we work in an "unschooled" fashion.
We had some discussion today about homeschooling versus "regular" school. Maizie told me there were a few reasons why she does not like "regular" school. This is new for her to communicate. Usually she would only cry about missing her previous teacher. Here is her list.
* I don't like the noise.
* I don't like kids asking me questions and being loud to me.
* I don't like the teacher making me go to the reading table. At the reading table I am there because I am loud and it makes me mad.
* I am loud because the kids talk loud and I talk loud and then I get in trouble.
* I get mad when the teacher makes me write on the chalk board.
* I don't like the noise of the teacher and her mean voice. (I don't think the teacher has a mean voice but it may be interpreted as such by Maizie...we have this same problem at church and with certain friends)
This is the most Maizie has ever told me about what she does not like about school. I asked her if she would like to go to regular school part time and she began to cry and said something like this,"Not the same school I was at before. I have to be the new kid at a school. I will only go if I am in second, third, sixth or tenth grade. I don't want the kids to talk to me and I don't want noise. I want regular school if this can be the deal."
Well, that does not sound too easy to write into an IEP. We talked about how children talk and part of making friends is talking. She went on to say she did not like homeschooling and she did not like regular school either. To top it all off she told me how she does not want to do any more math at tutoring.
Do I regret having this conversation? Yes and no. I am glad she can put her school dislikes into words. This tells me that if and when she is ready to return to regular school she may be able to better communicate her needs, difficulties and work with a teacher to solve problems rather than melting down, running out of the classroom or coming home and melting down for hours. I kind of regret asking because it tells me something is still not right with homeschooling and tutoring. Part of it is she does not like to do work that is difficult for her. Homeschooling is harder because we really know where she needs work and we work in these areas. At school aides often did much of the work for her and she would "fake" her way through assignments.
Now, we may wake up tomorrow and her attitude could be very different. Time will tell. For now homeschooling still seems to be our best option. She has been happier, has fewer seizures and is talking more. We are concerned with some regression in certain areas. I am thinking it would be worse if she was in school though. I guess I have no way of really knowing.
If time goes on and she still talks of wanting to go to "regular" school we may try a couple of hours per day. Soon she would be entering the really tough social years at school. The time when what you wear and how you behave become very important in the eyes of other students. I really can not imagine her coping with those pressures. I want her to feel comfortable keeping that unique "spark" that is Maizie.
As you can see I am sorting out my thoughts on the schooling issue today. I suppose it is natural when most everyone I know is sending the kids back to school tomorrow. For us, it is just another day with an extra bent to learning thrown in.
I will admit that I miss the days where I had more time to complete art work, read, visit friends and have time for myself. And yet, Maizie is so much more enjoyable to be around without public schooling. I don't miss phone calls or lack of phone calls from teachers. I certainly don't miss the routine from hell that was trying to get Maizie up and out for school. If she ever does go back she would only go in the afternoon. The mornings are too difficult for her. Her seizures are almost always in the morning.
God willing we will all wake up tomorrow and feel energetic and ready to live life in a learning way. That seems to be the best way to teach Maizie. Now, if I could just stop worrying about all of this. They say that takes time. It has been one year since we pulled her out of school. Maybe I am having some sort of bizarre anniversary stress.
Oh! We also see a new neurologist tomorrow that is much closer to home and would hopefully replace our child psychiatrist who has "disappeared".
Good luck to all of the kids returning to school, whether it be public, private or homeschooling! Hugs and prayers for all the parents worrying about all of the stresses that go along with special education.
16 comments:
Good luck with your first day back at Home Schooling! I loved the picture with her sleeping with the worksheets on top of her.
Her conversation with you was very interesting and gave a lot of insight into why that class setting was not right for her. I do think the righ teacher match can make all the difference in the world. With Melanie we were so lucky, the school listen to us when we told them what type of teaching style worked best for her. It fell apart in 7th grade, when middle school came. Up until that point, she did so well. High School is better, but middle school was tough. She was home schooled for a good portion of it, but I struggled with it because I know she needed social interactions. However, I would not tolerate anyone teasing or being mean to her. I was constantly on guard for that kind of stuff. So many teacher would say, "it' the age or kids will be kids," and that drove me crazy. I am sure the staff thought I was crazy!! Anyway, I really just wanted to say how much I admire how tuned in you are to Mazie's needs and even thou it is a tough choice, you are doing what is right for her now. What a wonderful mother you are.
Have a fun, happy teaching day!
I'll be thinking of you tomorrow and hoping your first day "back" goes smoothly. It sounds like you have looked at this schooling decision from all the different angles and made the best choice for right now. You deserve a LOT of credit for homeschooling; I'm sure it can be very challenging at times but it sounds like it is the best environment for Maizie.
I love the photo of her asleep under all those worksheets.
First: Charlie goes to sleep surrounded by "stuff" just like Maizie! Tonight he fell asleep on our bed and among the items were his backpack, various clothing item belonging to Jim or me, a picture schedule----he has been back to school since last Wednesday, but this weekend he was much more anxious than usual (and got really mad at me on Saturday afternoon). He ran right to bed on his own and fell asleep, very sweet and smiling.
Charlie was homeschooled for about 6 weeks and did not like it. He likes to get out of the house ... and he has to be in a special ed classroom and the student:teacher ratio is 1:1, and there are only a few children. It's interesting that Maizie seemed especially to point out noises as bothering her: Charlie often had frustrations about the other kids in his class when they talked to loud or in a high-pitched way. I hope the first day "back" and the neurologist visit go well---does the worry ever stop?
I hope everything goes well for you all as your start back with homeschooling - finding the right learning environment is certainly a challenge, and I think we always worry about it (I know I do). You've taken a great attitude to it though, and hopefully things will eventually fall into place for you. With all your hard work, you all really deserve for things to be successful.
We still have about 3 weeks until school starts back from the long summer break here in Australia. At this stage I am trying not to think too far ahead of myself as J transitions from preschool to a new school this year, and whilst our preparation has been very intense, it is incredibly difficult to face that moment of truth - will it go okay or will it not? Time will tell.
xx
All you said she told you was what she did NOT like. Did you ask her what she DID like about school, home schooling, her aids, learning, etc? Maybe she hasn't thought about that aspect of it, maybe it's never occured to her to see what the good things are about different situations?
No one said you had to follow a book for home schooling did they? So why not ask her what SHE wants to learn about. Just about everything can incorporate math (which she seems not to like to do the most)- cooking has fractions as well as conversions- how many teaspoons in a tablespoon-, music has fractions, counting change (banking) has adding and subtracting. A little creative 'out of the box' thinking and I'll bet she can learn all sorts of things without even knowing she's learning math (or science or astronomy or reading, etc)
Just an idea.
Great post, Marla. How exciting that Maizie was able to communicate that all to you. It gives so much perspective. I'm trying not to get ahead of myself with homeschooling as he is still 4, but I think homeschooling would stress me out. Wonder if there is another option...
Good luck on your first day of school!
Yes, it is so hard to know if we are making the right choices for our kids. I often wonder if school, any school, anywhere, is ever a comfortable fit.
It sounds, however, like Maizie is doing better at home and that's what you should focus on now. As time goes on, you'll be able to make little changes and tweak her schedule in a way that will hopefully keep her interested and happy.
Good luck today! And good luck with the new neurologist.
Wow, Marla, that is a lot to think about.
It seems like you are doing a fantastic job home schooling her. I'm coming in late on this, but I'm assuming school was not the best place for her? Was she full inclusion?
Hugs and warm prayers for you and joyous Maizie -
I agree that a pros list would be good as well (for both school and homeschool). Jamie hasn't been to school but I constantly stress to him that it's not a bad place, that he has friends who go, who like it. He has a lot of fears about school, he has a lot of fears of the unkown.
Anyway, Maizie seems likes a good list maker so that should be a good, positive experience.
Everyone- Thank you for your comments, encouragement and advice. I do appreciate it. I did ask Maizie what she liked about school and she was unwilling to share that list with me at this point. I asked again this morning and she became quite angry. She is often like that. So, when she is ready I may have a positive list to share. In the past it was mainly the social aspects of school that she enjoyed. Friends, staff and socializing.
MAYBE just MAYBE what you need to do is go back and read soem note from this time last year or write down things taht are different now. THAT will or should give you a HUDGE BOOST!!!!!!! hang in there. AND enjoy the good moments.
You are probably already doing something like this, but I thought I would mention how much success we have had with goals, tokens and rewards. Just simple stuff like scoring points for work done and trading in 50 or 100 points for a prize like a trip to a favorite restaurant or a toy really motivates our guy. It's particularly important for us to have these goals for things he does well in, so that the whole study experience is one of success and subjects that are harder and don't go so well seem less important and less of an imposition.
Marla, I hope the new neuro works out. :-)
All you can do is the best you can do...and you are already doing that. Homeschooling is hard...and we're only in the early preschool stuff at my house! LOL
You said, "Part of it is she does not like to do work that is difficult for her. Homeschooling is harder because we really know where she needs work and we work in these areas. At school aides often did much of the work for her and she would "fake" her way through assignments." I can relate to this as I watch Nik in PT or OT. He enjoys and excels at things he already does well and doesn't want to do the things that are harder or require more concentration. I'm not sure it's because he doesn't want to; sometimes I think it takes more energy and exhausts him to keep himself organized long enough to get through it. Usually after a few days of hte "hard" thing, he gets better and enjoys it.
We try to couple a favored activity with a new challenge so he (a) has a sense of success and stability and (b) isn't focusing so much on how hard the new stuff is.
Maybe you can try a similar apporach with Maizie and the things that are hard? Like someone else suggested...if she loves music, maybe find a way to incorporate the music into the math lesson (or vice versa), etc.
Sorry for the long-winded comment!
Just a mom-Very good idea! I will do that. A good use for a blog!:)
Vab-very good idea. No, we are not doing that with my homeschooling but she does it with tutoring. I will give it a shot.
niksmom-the tutor does work in riddles and stuff that she enjoys throughout the hour. With homeschooling I don't focus much on the math and do the stuff she likes more. But, like with Nik I have to encourage her...a lot...to challenge herself. Very good ideas you have in your comment. I will try some out. Thank you!
Wow - she's really doing a great job of sharing how she feels! That's got to be an encouragement. I laughed at your comment about it not being easy to write into an IEP : D And I loved the photo of her all sacked out with her worksheets - very cute : )
My son is in kindergarten, he is in full inclusion which means he is pulled out several times a day for special teaching. It is working good for him but we may need to reevaluate for next year.
Post a Comment