Day Two on Autism:The Musical...Thoughts Inspired by Wyatt
Wyatt is the son of Diane. Diane and Wyatt are having a heart to heart about Wyatt’s school situation.
Wyatt says, “One hundred percent of kids are retarded.” (In regards to his placement in a special needs classroom)
The mom asks,” Where do you want to be? Are you bullied in school?”
“Yes. When bullies grow up they get meaner.”
Click on the image above to view Wyatt talking with his mother about bullies.
I can speak from experience that Wyatt knows his stuff when it comes to bullies.
Wyatt talks a lot about bullying. I can’t begin to accurately describe the intense passion with which Wyatt describes bullies and what it is like to be at school with bullies. He has charisma and charm that defies description.
Elaine has the children do an exercise where they get to act out being bullies. Wyatt says, “It’s fun being a bully!”
A woman asks, “When you go back to school what are you going to do with real bullies?”
Wyatt looks at the camera and with great joy says, “That’s the mystery in the camera!”
Everything that Wyatt said holds a lesson for us to learn. He has insight into his own Autism and what it means to be Autistic. Wyatt sits swinging gently speaking on what it means to be in his own world and wonders why other people retreat into their own world. He is truly a child full of insight and is working hard to process what he knows and share it with us. Wyatt, like many people with Autism is a natural born teacher.
Most people think a child like Wyatt would be easy to place in school? He seems to hold his own and can speak. As the film went on many were probably shocked to hear that the parents were struggling to find a proper school placement for Wyatt. What they described is our experience with Maizie…completely. I am very glad this topic was brought up in the film. An entire film could be made around the struggle of Autistic children in schools. Or better yet…all children with special needs in schools.
Greg, Wyatt’s father explains that they are going to see an advocate/lawyer to help place Wyatt in a new school. The typical schools are not meeting Wyatt’s needs. Wyatt is not happy in the special needs classroom and wants to be mainstreamed.
To the parents surprise the lawyer reminds them that Wyatt has very low cognitive function. His test scores are low. I am assuming the parents were going to take the school to due process in order to fight for a private placement that would be paid by the state. They were vague so I am not certain. What is the cost for this lawyer’s service? A mere $430 per hour. If the case goes to due process it would run anywhere from twenty five to one hundred grand. Later the father says, “We’re pretty much fucked.”
Oh, how I know that feeling. According to HBO’S site Wyatt was able to get into a school especially for children with special needs and is doing well.
I am certain that is not the end result for most of our children. I have written about advocating with the schools before by giving my top list of tips. Even with my ongoing advocacy training and success with securing one to one aides for other students I was unable to secure a good school match for my daughter. There are no good choices for her schooling where we live. Private schools that are specially designed for Autistic children do not exist here. There are more families choosing home schooling for their Autistic child. I don’t know if I would really describe it as a true choice for us. It is more of a last resort.
Like Wyatt, Maizie did not fit into a special needs classroom. She longed to be with the mainstream classroom but zoned out and had little comprehension while there. Maizie was continually paranoid that children were laughing at her even when it was evident they were not. Her social skills were far behind her peers and she sensed it. Every evening she would cry and scream over what she perceived to be happening at school. Eventually we had to act as if it was happening and withdraw her from school for the sake of her own sense of self.
I would love to know more about Wyatt’s struggles in school and how this new school has been better for him. The focus always seems to be on everything but helping the kids that are here now. The press is all about the vaccines, the environment, the struggle and very little attention is placed on schooling and what we can do right here…right now…to help our children and adults with Autism.
What kind of supports would be helpful? I will start by asking our children and adults with Autism what they need. But will I be listening? Are viewers really listening to what children with Autism are saying in Autism: The Musical?
In everyday life it seems many of us are busy arguing the cause or the cure for Autism. I have forced ‘techniques’ on my daughter that obviously go against who she is. All because I want her to conform, to fit in to a world that often excludes the very essence that is her. Why do I do that?
Wyatt, Maizie and many other children are talking to us and we are so far off into our own world that we are not listening. Could it be at all possible that I am sometimes the bully in Maizie’s life? I don’t intentionally hurt her and never want to cause her stress so by definition I am not a bully. There was an underlying message in regards to bullying that was so strong in this film I have to question myself. I can’t ignore it.
If I know that certain ‘techniques’ or daily situations I force my child into cause her negative stress and physically bother her and yet I persist does that make me a bully? Sometimes, for my own reasons I force her to follow through, I coerce her to make eye contact, to speak to someone she does not want to speak to, insist she eat what she can’t tolerate and touch what repulses her, to stay seated, to go to a store she begs me not to, to hug when she does not want to be touched, to conform and fit in when she can not…and the list goes on. There is a better way.
I believe Wyatt is on to something with his interest in bullying. Are we hearing him? What are we doing with the information our children are giving us? They are all speaking to us. Whether through written words, the spoken word, sign language, movement, music, aggression, silence or art…are you paying attention?
20 comments:
Wow, Marla, this was one hell of a powerful post. Your question
"If I know that certain ‘techniques’ or daily situations I force my child into cause her negative stress and physically bother her and yet I persist does that make me a bully?" really hit a nerve.
This is a really stupid example but getting anything remotely healthy into SB has been a big struggle lately. And so I continue to feed him one of the three fruits he will eat. It takes him a solid hour to consume a bowl of one of these. He could chew one small piece of apple for 30 minutes .... I swear, I'm not kidding. I'm constantly telling him to chew and swallow, let's go, this doesn't have to take all day, blah blah blah. As I said, a dumb example, but bottom line this is part of our day I've come to dread (I'm guessing he does too) but I can't just give up and allow him not to consume ANY produce, can I? Oh and rewards, bribes, consequences ... yeah, we've tried them all .... it's still a royal nightmare.
Anyway, sorry for rambling. But I will be re-reading this post. You've definitely given me food for thought.
I thought what Wyatt was saying was profound and honest. We clearly can learn a lot from this little boy about how peers treat kids perceived as different. It was heartbreaking to listen to, but needed to be said. You could tell it was on his mind, all the time. I too, would like to know more about what happened to Wyatt, and how he is doing socially now.
I personally, don't see why Elaine had to make such a big deal about the eye contact. I think that comes with comfort and when the kids are not feeling over stimulated. I know with Melanie, she use to tell me it hurt, to look directly in our eyes.
I want to watch this again. Trying not to judge, but of the parents really upset me.
Overall, great show and I am so glad they did it.
XOXOX
I haven't seen the movie yet, but I will soon.
As for the bullying, based on your description of "parental bullying" I think you may be feeling guilty over the wrong things. If I gave in to every one of my typical 3 year old child's whims just because I didn't want to let him have negative feelings, I would be doing him a disservice. Some times my little one is more particular and stubborn than J. I think we all as parents have to teach all of our children, autistic or not, that the world exists outside of their heads. We have to, or they will all rule us. Little J wishes he was in charge, but he just can't be, not all the time anyway.
I hope that made sense, it did in my head.
Wonderful post! Listening to Wyatt really gave me such insight, made me think. He's such a bright youngster who has so much to offer :)
The children in the musical were awesome, Neal reminded me of K.C. so much! I was so happy to see non verbal kiddos included in the musical as well.
This has really given me lots to think about... I'll have to go back and read again as I think I'm still processing it all!
And I definitely have to see the movie now!
xx
I agree with Graceunderautism. As our kids mature, we just cannot let them always do what feels best to them. Especially if they are high-functioning. We must mold them and doing so we inevitably make mistakes, but it is better to make mistakes than resign one's parental duty.
About the particular problem with Maizie's school placement - I think that the vomiting makes it quite complicated.
I haven't had any issues as a child but, for some reasons, I felt so unhappy about using the school toilet that prefered to wait many hours until returning home. I even didn't know where the toilets of my elementary school were located.
Schools are hailed for allowing socialization but people don't like to socialize when performing their bodily functions, especially the "less aesthetic" ones - going to the toilet, vomiting.
i loved that wyatt and his talk about bullies. he reminded me of fluffy. so did henry. both of them embody so much of fluffy's strengths and characteristics and struggles. fluffy would be eaten alive in a regular school and would be pained in a special needs classroom unless it was a particularly perfect one. that's why we homeschool.
i was glad his story was included in this film so others could get a peek into what it's like for this sort of child. i couldn't stand that advocate! looking at the cognitive test scores on paper as if that had any bearing on wyatt's abilities.
Wow! I have to see this movie. Your posts about it have left me speechless. You have a gift for introspection and the strength to do it.
I couldn't believe that Wyatt had "low cognitive function". The way he expresses himself... He's wise beyond his years. He might have trouble in some subjects, but I bet he'll be able to go to college someday, where people value expertise and uniqueness.
I have a friend here in Northern California with an HFA son (not as high functioning as Wyatt) and he goes to a regular middle school in a high-functioning special ed classroom. His brother, who is non-verbal, severely autistic, goes to a different class more geared to low functioning kids, but it's still in a regular (public) Elementary School.
Great Post with deep insights. Wish I could say more, but my boy on spring break needs some attention.
His Mid-michigan schooling situation is less than perfect as well. There is no wonder as to why so parents in our community opt for home schooling. For many children it's the best option.
Great post. In my opionin, you have to sometimes teach kids by making them do things. I don't think it's bullying, but teaching. Sometimes just a little push is all they need to learn something or to become less afraid or familiar with something. In Neils case, I think his mother really pushes. You can clearly see that she is the only one enjoying his birthday party. As for Parker, we have small parties for him with just a few people because that he is how he reacts. (Sorry if you already posted about this and I missed it) I'm really nervous about the bullying thing once Parker gets into school. That is something I'm trying not to think of at the moment. Great post. Lots of insite.
This is a really powerful post. I think some of the comments you have received are interesting as well. It's so hard as parents to know where the line between bullying and empowering is. Perhaps we only know in hindsight. If our child is able to overcome their fear, then we've empowered, if we make it worse or no improvement, then we've bullied. Of course, so much harder if your child is unable or struggles with communication.
Wonderful. provactive posts, as usual.
powerful post! really got me thinking! thanks for posting it!
I understand what you are saying. I think that when we started aba with bubs, it was really a dilemma for me. I still have a hard time with some of the things bubs' school thinks I should do, from their behavioral approach standpoint. I think the diffence lies in pushing your child to achieve more, as opposed to forcing them to do something they cannot. It's a tough call but I agree with those who say that there are things typical children don't want to do that they have to. Hey, I don't want to pay my phone bill sometimes.
I was also shocked when Wyatt's parents went to that advocate and he spoke about his low cognitive funcitoning. He has such emotional intelligence, wise beyond his years.
One of the roles of a parent is, unfortunately, to push and stretch and mold our kids. If we did not do that we would be, at best, domestic servants and, at worst, the sort of thoughtless, disconnected caregivers we worry about in institutions.
Our SLP put it to me this way. She said, you are the only people who can effectively push your guy, because he knows that you love him.
We don't have to push our kids to be something that they cannot happily be, but I think that helping them to push their own envelopes is a big part of our jobs.
Everyone is leaving great comments. I do think some of what I am saying is not being understood. That is okay.
I am thinking more along the lines of what we do with our children in therapies, with trying to make them conform or do things that may not be necessary at a certain time. I am not speaking of chores, or making the bed or other day to day things. I am wanting us to think about the things that affect our children on a more intense, subconscious level.
Forcing eye contact, certain clothing that must be worn, pushing past food sensitivities, forcing communication when it is not going to work for that child at that particular moment no matter what you do. Certain behavioral strategies that possibly cause more stress, more harm that good.
We have rules in our home. M is not just given whatever she wants. She is well mannered, respectful and we have worked very hard with her to teach her these things. But, it is the way in which we taught her that has definately changed over time. I can look back now and see that much of the therapies and techniques we were using were counterproductive for her.
If a certain technique works for your child that is fantastic. But, for M many things professionals told us to do caused more aggression and frustration.
She was not pulled from school because of her CVS. She has apparently always had CVS but it was never to the point where it affected her education severely until this last December when we were homeschooling all ready. M was pulled from school for many many reasons and most of them were directly due to the schools inability to meet her needs.
Thank you again for your comments and taking the time to read my thoughts on this amazing movie. I may write more about it soon.
"Could it be at all possible that I am sometimes the bully in Maizie’s life? "
This is a point that all parents need to think about----maybe part of being a parent is to be that "authority figure" who is insistent about getting out of bed, not eating an entire carton of ice cream, practicing piano...but Charlie doesn't talk back and he ends up with more people giving him orders than do many.
Your posts on the movie are the best I've read---thoughtful, critical, and personal.
I couldn't believe that Wyatt had "low cognitive function". The way he expresses himself... He's wise beyond his years.
Both Wyatt and Henry reminded me of my son. I am not surprised by Wyatt's scores though it really ticked me off the way the lawyer put so much weight on them (though perhaps he was just being realistic, explaining how the school would present things it's hard to tell.) My son is extremely verbal, so much so that we had a hard time getting anyone to evaluate him and had several people try to convince us that the troubles he was having were due to him being "too smart" and "bored in school". As it turns out on the Woodcock/Johnson eval he scored below the charts on processing speed and short term memory while scoring normal to high in other areas. Those verbal skills can be decieving that way.
Marla,
I hope you don't mind and can understand why my comment I've been trying write for your post is going to end up being a post on my blog instead.
I've been having offline distractions all day while trying to concentrate on wording my reply here, but while I'm composing my thoughts as I look at your page with all these thought provoking comments, I'm battling composing a book.
I even talked with my daughter about this. She said I need to write a book. She understands why I'm struggling here. I don't want to write a book. That's why I blog, but posts are not that much easier to do than comments.
I'm going to try to give my insight on your recent post about Autism: The Musical on my blog instead. I hope I have better success at it there than I have so far here.
I already wrote one long and thorough comment here, but somehow it got accidentally deleted because the window got closed without my being able to save it.
My name is Neil and I have spent over a decade working with children with Autism utilizing ABA based treatment. I understand the daily struggles that the families go through as well as the innumuerable sacrifices that are made. That said Wyatt is truly an inspirational human being and tipifies what I love about these kids. Children like him give families, tutors and program managers the motivation to fight the daily battles and revel in the small victories. Cheers to you you and your family, your story only helps bring awareness to the epeidemic and gives us all inspiration.
my sincere thanks for your courage to share your story!!!!
Post a Comment