Saturday, October 4, 2008

The Kirton Family, My Thoughts on Autism x 6

Okay. So did anyone watch Autism x6? A show on Discovery Health about Amazing Families. We did. I have seen the Kirton family they pictured on other interviews before. They have their own blog Autism Bites (not liking the title any) and foundation. Hopefully some of the home renovations from this foundation would go towards their own home. I know these parents love their children very much and yet I found much of what was going on very disturbing.It may seem odd to care so much but when people watch these shows they will think that this is what life is like with all Autistic children. Even worse, they will think that some of the tactics used within this household are acceptable. This show was a giant step backwards in the advocating for special needs children.

Here is a bullet point list of what I found disturbing.
*In the interviews I saw and the show the children never have bedding on their beds. The reason being that they have accidents or tear the bedding off. Why not as sit the children in learning to keep the bedding on? Buy clips or sheets that wrap totally around the mattress to protect it and keep the bedding in tact. It looked terrible and can not be comfortable.

*The children are allowed to tear at the walls, removing it little by little. One little girl in particular was said to do this as she layed in bed. The wall was torn down to the brown board. Is it too hard to redirect an autistic child so that they have something else to rip and tear? Something appropriate could be used. If a child is being allowed to destroy a wall that child is not being watched carefully. The child may require sleeping in the parents bedroom until the behavior can be stopped.

*A little boy was shown belted onto a kitchen chair as the dad cut his hair. The dad explained that he would be squirming all over the chair if they did not belt him in. There are more appropriate ways to do this. A booster seat with a built in belt would look a lot better and would certainly be more comfortable/safer than the dad's belt. This one really concerned me. We all advocate and work very hard for our children never to be held down or tied down and then they show this as being a great technique. It made me sick.

*The father at one point made a comment about working hard to make her daughter "more human". Ummm.....need I say more as to why this is inappropriate language when discussing Autism?

*The parents have a large piece of wood that closes off the kitchen to the children. Once again, is this a farm? Why not use one of the many baby gates that can be purchased inexpensively to restrict this area? When I saw the wooden divider that was as tall as the parents I was shocked. Not only is it unsafe because a child and adult can not even see through it but it looks like they are caring for farm animals not children. If one thinks I am focusing on what something "looks like" well, yes I am! It is very important not to treat people like they are animals no matter what their physical or mental challenges are.

These are just a few of the concerns I had in regards to this program. The family is looked up to as an example of how to care for Autistic children. I am sure the family was chosen due to the large family size and that all of their children are Autistic. The deplorable conditions in the house also adds to the sensationalism of the show.

The family is being studied. I do hope that includes complete genetic studies on the parents and children. This family could be a huge help in that area. It would seem to make sense that there is a huge genetic possibility going in within this family. Unfortunately, I doubt that is part of the study.

My final thought in regards to this show will upset some people. I don't mean for it to do so. Obviously, this family is overwhelmed. They have their hands full. All six of their children are Autistic and of varying degrees. Why do people have more children than they can afford to take care of? Why do they have more children than they have the energy for? Raising a child with Autism is very expensive. Raising six children with Autism would be beyond expensive. It is no wonder the family struggles to afford proper tools in the home to assist with the care and direction of these children. They mention in the link above that they have no space in their 1, 100 square foot (3 bedrooms, 1 bath and no basement) home for these six children. Why would one not consider the fact of not having enough space for six children before having six children?

It is beyond my understanding when so many children in this world go without homes and care that people give birth to so many children and are unable to care for them properly. Oh, I so know I will upset people with that comment and I am sorry. But, it just makes sense to me to limit the amount of children we have so that we can care for each one in the best way possible.

The Kirton family has their hands full. I am sure the blessings are huge and the challenges as well. I hope that their family begins to focus more on the blessings within their family and sharing that on their blog.

29 comments:

Anonymous said...

I didn't se it so perhaps I shouldn't comment (but why let that stop me). Have the parents been assessed? Seriously.

Sheri said...

I haven;t seen the show so I cannot comment on what I saw, but if your assessment is accurate, which I don't doubt, I would be irritated as well.

THey actually showed the kid belted onto a kitchen chair, and the father truly said "more human"???? Are you kidding? Deplorable.

Now I have to go watch the show.

Thanks for not shying away from showing your true opinions. I love that about you. As you know, I have NO tact ! LOL

Anonymous said...

I did not see this show, but will certainly watch and see if it is on again. The points that you made certainly make sense to me. I find what you were concerned about very disturbing. I especially agree with people having more children than they can care for. I see that over and over again in my job, with kids without special needs. It is so frustrating.

I am glad you had the courage to express your honest opinions.

Also wanted to let you know that I am starting a private blog, related to the girls and my issues. I would love it if you would be a part of it. I'll e-mail you more about it and my reasonings.

XXXXXXX

Melissa Jo said...

Great post! Sounds like an 'interesting' story told by that family. I agree on all your points ten fold--especially the last one (perhaps that's the burnt out social worker voice in me talking but it is the cold hard truth.)It sounds very sad, really and I hate to think that they are being used as a model for families raising children with autism---how frusterating! Thanks for the post, it was really interesting!

Col said...

From the Kirton family website - "When each baby came we felt there was still one more little child waiting in Heaven to be a part of our family."

I'm with you on this one Marla. I just don't get it. Obviously this family is dealing with a heavy load, I don't understand how this wasn't obvious to them after their third or fourth child. I'm also aware my comment might offend some people, but for goodness sake they seem like intelligent people. Sure, get that little feeling from Heaven (or wherever) but check the bank balance too.

Essential Amy said...

Haven't seen it.
We stopped at one for the very reason you speak of.
I just don't understand why people go on these shows and it seems somewhat irresponsible of the producers to 'sensationalize' autism in such a way. I think autism needs a p.r. person.

tulipmom said...

I haven't had the chance to watch this yet.

We took the controversial measures (ie... Microsort) we did for the very reasons you mentioned.

Earlier this week a stranger actually said to me "Imagine if you had six autistic kids like that family on (that show)......"

How is one supposed to respond to a comment like that??

little.birdy said...

This is going to sound horrible, but I took my dog to the vet yesterday and they have a sheet of plastic bolted over the wall behind the examining table for ease of cleaning and protecting the wallpaper. It would not be too expensive to do something similar for the child who is destroying her wall. Does she do that other places too? Sheesh. That struck me as the strangest thing of all to just ignore...

Bobbi said...

Marla,
I was thinking almost all the same things as you. That house was a wreck and how can that even be healthy. It's almost like the kids live like animals. I'm not them, and I've only seen one day of their family, so maybe I don't understand their situation. I know I am overwhelmed with just one child with autism. That said, I still think you are totally right. Who lets their kids up on the counter near a knife or peel the wall apart? I think these people are in over their heads!

Stinking Billy said...

marla, it's hard to believe that the parents are not only getting away with such inhumanity towards their children, but actually being encouraged by others who should know better. But, TV programme makers are not known for behaving responsibly, just clawing-in ratings. This one takes some beating!

Anonymous said...

I don't see the show listed again for this week, so maybe it was just a one time documentary? That is too bad, really. I was hoping that it would be ongoing, and maybe would lead to some support and help that the family needs. The chaos in that house can't be helping matters any!

Club 166 said...

I haven't seen the show, so take what I say with a grain of salt.

Having come from a family of six kids, the number alone doesn't bother me so much (though I wouldn't have minded if my parents stopped after two kids-can you guess where I am in the birth order?).

But I do sympathize totally with the notion of only have as many kids as you can take care of (financially, emotionally, etc.). My wife and I struggle at times with two (and she's a "stay at home" mom!). Don't know what we'd do with six.

The bedding issue strikes me as child neglect, as there are certainly ways to keep bedding on. We have gone through periods where bedding needed to be cleaned every day, but you do what you have to do.

In regards the "tearing at the walls", this is another thing that we have had to deal with. Buddy Boy is more self restrained now, but has had periods where he would pick at the walls, gouge out his headboard on the bed, windowsills, etc. Painting his fingernails with that nasty tasting stuff they use to keep you from chewing them, wearing gloves at night, close observation, and listening on a monitor to his room throughout the night have all been instrumental in lessening the effect of this, but I'm sure that a lot of it has been just waiting it out, too. As Buddy Boy has matured, he has gotten a lot more control in this area.

The dad's use of language sounds deplorable. What a message to send to your child.

Thanks for reviewing this. Unfortunately, I believe in the 10:1 publicity principle (for every 1 bit of bad publicity, you have to have 10 good ones to cancel it out). All the rest of us can do is try to put 10 good things out there regarding autistics anytime we see something like this.

Joe

Ashley's Mom said...

I can't believe Child Protective Services has not gotten involved.

I'm with you on all your views expressed...

Bonnie said...

Wow Marla, I tell ya, I hadn't heard about that documentary, but from your summary, I can tell I would be feeling the same way. Your bullet points were interesting and I am sure I would have felt the same way had I seen this.

Sometimes it's hard to judge someone when you aren't in their shoes, but like you said, you know there are ways that are more humane and acceptable to deal with issues. Sounds like they are just doing what they can. Are there no O.T.s in their area? I need to watch this thing!

floating in space said...

I have not seen the show but will check it out. You raise some very valid points.

Anonymous said...

I'm with you. I don't like the name of their blog. I suppose they consider "bites" to be a clever play on words (bites/bytes) but it's disrespectful to people who have autism.
I, too, am appalled by they way they keep house. It seems institutional and cruel not to make children sleep on bare mattresses and to hold them onto a chair with a belt. I suspect the little girl peels the wallpaper off because she's not stimulated enough. if I had to live in a bare room I'D be peeling the wallpaper!
What;s wrong with giving her some old magazines to tear? Why not decorate the walls with those colorful plastic stencils that are easy to put on and remove?
The tee-shirts, are insulting, too. They seem confrontational and rude. Yes, I know people stare when they see someone behaving oddly but I think there are better ways to get the message across. The attitude the senior Kirtons seem to take is that autistic children are like wild animals that have to be penned up and can't control themselves. yes, they clearly love their children but I don't think they're helping them become a part of the larger world.

Tara said...

I haven't seen the show, but this doesn't sound like a good situation. I know it isn't the popular view to take, but I wonder why people have more children than they can provide for (physically, financially and emotionally, in any circumstance). Everyone is human and deserves to be treated as such, with dignity and respect.

Drama Mama said...

Now I HAVE to see the show; I hope it repeats.

Anonymous said...

They're the one's that made up those t-shirts along the lines of "yes I'm bad, but I have autism" paraphrasing.

They have been under the care of CAS and I believe if you go back about a year or so.. near the beginning of the blog the children were taken away. Also, at that time the Mother was assessed for depression etc.

We too stopped at 2 - both with ASD - for the reasons mentioned. Just b/c you could, doesn't mean you should.

Dadof6Autistickids said...

Dear Marla,

The post you have on your blog has caused me to start the creation of a FAQs page on our website: www.AutismBites.com and blog: http://autismbitestheblog.blogspot.com/. Sorry you don’t like the name, but it is one of the things we will address on the FAQs page.
When I read your post I wondered if we watched the same program. I was surprised at the tone of your post, especially after reading your bio. You say, “I do not claim to have the answers in regards to Autism”. It appears that you have the answers for us though. Your bio also says, “How we choose to help our daughter progress is a personal and difficult decision. I respect that others may choose different paths for progress.” Once again it looks like WE do not have your respect. Lastly on your bio you state …”God wants my attention focused on my daughter. And yet, through acceptance I feel I am given great power to move forward.” We too feel that God has helped us with this chosen path to help our children and we could use a little acceptance.

A few rebuttals to your ‘observations’ are in order.

The lack of sheets on the beds and teaching the children to not take them off? Count your blessing that you do not have two classic Autistic children, you have no idea. Teach them? Sarah just learned to use a fork, sometimes, at mealtime. Ammon has no interest. Keeping bedding in place is a much more complex task.

The tearing of the walls? Ditto.

Using a belt to keep them in a chair during meals or haircutting? Children need to be restrained for their own safety. Would you be against seatbelts in a car also? It is similar, should I let my son bounce around so much that I nick an ear. It’s not like they are ‘tied down’ and left alone. It’s not punishment, it’s so they will not be hurt.

The “more human” comment that you attributed to me? Way off base. That was said by Sarah’s special education teacher. I do need to talk to him and find out exactly what he meant. Being around a number of educators, I’d imagine that he was meaning that he is hoping Sarah will one day be able to have a complete human experience. Or in other words be like you and me.

The large piece of wood blocking off the kitchen? First off that was the approved method from our local CPS. That answers another person’s ‘concern’. We joke that CPS has us on speed dial. Could you imagine most of the commenter’s here living in our neighborhood and sending CPS after us each week. We are glad that we have, mostly, more understanding neighbors then this group. The ‘gate’, as we call it, was our last resort. We went through three of the baby gates you recommended. Ammon got over each one and broke them all to pieces. We even tried a truck bed cargo netting, but cute little Ammon would get in between the bungee cords. Then he would empty the cupboards, toss dishes, pans, and flour, sugar and cereal boxes. He’d clean out the frig, get on top and throw things off. He was a one man (baby) wrecking crew. So far Ammon has not been able to break or get over this ‘gate’. We don’t know what we’ll do when he gets older.

Well, that handles most the egregious misconceptions. Please read our blog to get it directly from us and not assume that someone else knows more than us… the actual parents going through it all.

I know you probably meant well and were concerned, but if something doesn’t seem right… just ask. Thanks.

John Kirton, Dad of 6 Autistic Kids

Anonymous said...

OK, I'm glad it wasn't just me -- I really tried to reserve judgment since I don't have an autistic child, but I kept thinking, "there HAS to be a better way" regarding some of the things that were done. I think you are an incredible voice for the autistic community, Marla.

kristina said...

thanks for this, Marla (no TV here......)----and thanks for asking hard questions that need to be discussed.

Anonymous said...

Hmm...I read your review and then I scrolled through the comments and saw John Kirton's rebuttal, so that killed most of my own comment. I didn't watch the show anyway, but I do agree with you on one point. If parents (being general here & not directly talking about the Kirtons) don't have the means or the ability to care for so many kids, maybe they should practice contraception. We also knew by the time our second was born (right around the time Gus was being diagnosed) that it was going to be a tough road, so in fairness to the kids and ourselves we chose to stop at 2...

Changed my mind - I will comment. My kids used to take the sheets off the bed constantly. I was constantly telling them 'no' and constantly remaking the beds. There is a 'rule' that beds are not for playing. It's a very time consuming and often frustrating process, but that's part of what you sign up for when you choose to become a parent - to teach your children. Same thing with the walls. My son doesn't tear the walls to shreds, but he does get ketchup/sauce all over them (or anything else on his hands) and the curtains - everywhere. Do I run after him with a spray bottle to clean them? No. My walls looked awful for a long time. I finally started making him wash his hands after meals. So perhaps Sarah does need to be given an alternative solution. Teaching doesn't necessarily have to mean sitting a child down and drilling them on a concept. It can be subtle and autistic children can learn- just in different ways and maybe the curve is longer. And just to offer a different possible solution to the large piece of wood? Would a door or a half, maybe 3/4 door (that one could see over) work?

I'm not trying to be judgmental here because I don't know what it's like to raise more than one child with special needs. But I do have 2 children who can be rambunctious, high spirited and can be challenging. I certainly don't have all the answers, and while I would agree that all families living with special needs could use a bit of compassion and understanding, they are also not inviting the world into their homes. You've got to expect that there will be criticism when you do that.

I wish the Kirtons well - they certainly have their work cut out for them. And Marla, as always, I wish you and Maisie well.

Mom26children said...

Parenting children is a hard job. Autism just adds to the mix.
As a parent of 5 children with Autism, I must remember that first, I have children who need parenting. 2nd, these children have Autism.
I have spoken with John and Robin on the phone before. They are very nice people. I know they are doing the best they know how to do.
I do agree with some of the comments...sorry John and Robin...
I know you must pick your battles, but you also have to raise children to be responsible and respectful of everyone and everything. This has to start at home....

Jeanette

kristi said...

I did watch this, and I blogged about it as well. I didn't think the living conditions were that great. I am not the cleanest person in the world, but my walls have paint and my beds have sheets. I was telling HUBS that atleast they could put up paneling, or something?? The Mom said that a lot of days she is too tired but to sit and watch tv ALL DAY LONG. Give me a break. And neither of them work. The kids are all in school.

I have TC, who is autistic, he IS verbal but he is a handful. I work all day, and come home and I even went back to school (online courses) so it is not easy, but it can be done. I know they have 6 kids but it was obvious that the kids are not watched well.

I know they love their kids but there comes a time when you have to pull your head out of your butt and PUSH FORWARD.

Tiffany T. said...

I just got through watching the show, and I was horrified to say the least.

I do not myself have any experience with autistic children but I know neglect and unsanitary conditions when I see them.

I do not understand why people would continue to have children (especially children who need alot of love/care/attention, when they do not have the money or time to give to each child.) Looking at their home I was shocked. No its not the size of them home, you can do alot with a little. It was the mess everywhere, piles of clothes, baskets. Plywood...I saw that it was "CPS" approved but still. If you have a little one prone to climbing, couldn't he get some nasty splinters??

Regarding the adorable little guy that climbs everything. WHY would you have a wall mounted TV in his room??? You know he climbs, do you not think that he could pull that down onto himself???

The no sheets is disgusting. It honestly looked like that room was in a third world country. When the child took his diaper off on the bare mattress and dropped feces on it which the father acknowledged they needed to "wipe off" Im sorry but that is disgusting. You let your children sleep on that mattress with no sheet. Do they have sheets on thier bed?? Seriously. Put some elastic straps on the sheets. Just because these children have autism does not mean that they should be treated this way. Is it because they "dont know anybetter" Sick.

The oldest child was doing work everytime I saw him. Sweeping, getting his siblings dressed, cleaning etc. The mother just sat around telling him what to do.

These people disgust me, and yeah that sounds harsh but its the truth. I felt so sorry for these kids. No one should have to live in such filth. Its not your childrens fault that you continued to have more kids despite your small home and lack of resources. Why should they pay the price? With so many special needs children you KNOW they are not all getting the individual attention that they need. If they were children would not be getting on the counter with knives, tearing up walls, or destroying sheets and writing all over everything.

I think CPS needs to dig a little deeper, or just watch this program because those children need help.

morbidyorkie said...

I have now seen this show three times on Discovery Health and get angrier each time I watch it. I think they should have called it "heathenism x 6" I would not even let me dogs run through that house. I'm really disappointed that Discovery Health would promote this show. I want to know where they get their money from if neither perent works?

I worked with people with autism in the past and yes....they can understand what simple boundaries are like you don't pull your diaper off and poop on the bed.

The kids have no boundaries and no manners. When they were at that resturaunt, if I had been dining there, I would have asked the manager to ask them to leave.

How gross and nasty.

Enraged in Tennessee said...

When my husband and I watched it we thought WOW, that's us! Our now 5 year old son's room...(which is monitored by a remote camera security camera) has ruined carpet (although constantly cleaned with carpet cleaning machine), wainscot paneled lower 1/2 walls to cover up holes and plaster lathing and remnants of 100 year old historic wallpaper that remained after going on a peeling and picking frenzy....a wall mounted tv (TOO HIGH to climb onto like one person said in the blog)....ridiculous..., plexiglass covering both windows (for obvious reasons), a toddler bed (Bolted to the floor for obvious reasons) with his mattress DUCT TAPED on both ends to keep him from destroying it (his 3rd)..abt sheets..we gave up on that a long time ago....."clips" and "straps" etc...garbage...they won't work with a destructive and determined autistic child....we got old sheets and sewed them together like a huge pillowcase...put the mattress in it and folded the end up and secured the end. It works GREAT!....It is so easy for people to judge when they DON'T have autistic children OR their children's autism is not as severe or has different symptoms......we use a seat with a belt for time outs since that is exactly what the school he goes to uses. As parents we love our children and have their best interests at heart, one being their safety. For some children conventional safety items and guidelines WILL NOT WORK so you have find what WILL work. It may not be pretty but if it works then that is ALL that matters. Not everyone has the same support and resources as others and instead of faceless uneducated, ignorant (yes, look up the definition!), and obviously unempathetic retorts and judgements why don't you put all that energy into volunteering to HELP people who need it? HELP them try to make things easier and better for them AND their children (that you SEEM to be SO WORRIED ABOUT) instead of passing judgement on them and turning your nose up at them! Unless you are WILLING and ACTIVELY DO SOMETHING to make things better or to better educate YOURSELF....I would suggest you to BACK OFF, because I can guarantee that NOT ONE of you that judged this family can WALK ON WATER and until you can then..... well, I'm sure you know where you can go. :0)
"Judge not lest ye be judged".....your day is coming.

Unknown said...

Amen and Halleluja to Enraged in Tennessee - someone said EXACTLY what I was going to! Thanks ET!! Let's all start helping instead of judging. Don't know where to start? Do some reserach in your community for Autism Support Groups - I'm sure they would accept help with open arms! The power of Life and Death lies in the tounge! Choose LIFE!