Mentally Retarded....the term is changing?
Everyone who knows me is aware that I do not like the word, "retard". I especially don't like to hear someone call another person a "retard". I can't stand it when people say, "That is so retarded!". It is rare that I will say anything when an adult swears or uses a hurtful term. I am as guilty as anyone when it comes to having a potty mouth. I see some value in swearing and expressing myself verbally. But this word is one I do not use. This word has been known to make me speak out immediately.
Where does my dislike for the word retarded come from?
My sister had a stroke when she was six years old. Her special needs meant that I grew up around other children with special needs and some were diagnosed as mentally retarded. I remember learning the word "retarded". My sister is not diagnosed as mentally retarded but I do have painful memories of hearing other kids at school saying cruel things like, "Your sister is so retarded and so are you!" And at the same time I remember overhearing conversations about certain children being diagnosed as "mentally retarded".
As a child this confused me. I knew right away that my sister having special needs affected how my sister and me were perceived by others. When I heard children and even adults calling other people retarded in a cruel way I was taken aback. How could someone have a diagnosis of mental retardation and at the same time people were calling people with and without disabilities "retarded"? It was easy to put two and two together and realize that the diagnosis of mentally retarded was being misused. I hated the sound of the word as well. Most of all I hated the pain that word caused others.
Today I found out that Maizie's MR Waiver (Mental Retardation Waiver) has been changed to the ID Waiver (Intellectual Disability Waiver). I have not seen this change on any paper work and most case workers and medical professionals use the term MR Waiver.
Even after hating the word "retarded" for years I was surprised to find myself not liking the new term either. It is a big improvement but I still don't like it. Possibly, I will never be pleased with the language surrounding special needs. What would I call it if it was up to me? I have no idea. I do know however that the terms never seem to fit my daughter or anyone I know that is diagnosed as such. And yet, the diagnosis or label is necessary to acquire services.
In this house the word "retarded" is frowned upon. It has been banned. I have walked in on one of the girls looking right at Maizie and saying, "You are so retarded!" I about fell to the floor. Did she have any idea what she was saying? Did she know that she was calling a child with a diagnosis of mental retardation "retarded'? No. She did not.
Maizie has begun to put the terms together as she hears me discussing services on the phone or reads papers I am working on. I watch as she processes how the terms are being thrown around and I can see a look of concern.
I explained to Chris and the girls why I don't appreciate the term being used in this house. And yet, I still hear it every now and then. I have even said "retarded" in bad way on occasion! I was beyond shocked when I did. It is a hurtful word that has permeated our culture despite also being a required diagnosis for many services. Confusing for sure.
Comedies seem to be all about throwing the term in whenever possible. You all know the controversy surrounding "Tropic Thunder". I saw the movie and I loved it despite its use of the word. I know. I'm not necessarily proud of that fact but I love all the Coen Brothers movies.
What is it about this term that is so pervasive in our culture? Other negative terms come and go but this one seems to be stuck.
10 comments:
Until the expression "Aspie" is used and only used by people on the Autism Spectrum, it remains as offensive and demeaning to me as Retarded, and, horror of horrors, the N-word...
This was a great post! I too have 'banned' the word 'retarded' in our home. My husband just asked me if I was 'retarded or something' the other day and I answered "no, but apparently thats the diagnosis of our 14 year old, so what are you trying to say?" I dont think I talked to him for 5 hours after that bc he thought i was just being "too P.C."
I sometimes struggle with "is it just being overly p.c." in a day and age where it does sometimes go overboard. yet, everytime i hear it, i cringe. Moron and Idiot used to be used to describe the 'cognitively imparied" decades ago, and the general public hijacked those words too in their common vernacular. Those labels dont exist anymore, so the words carry no second meaning. The problem is, "mentally retarded" still exists as a term, so when someone says "retarded" in slang, it is offensive... I know my daughter's diagnosis on Axis II is "Severe-Profound Mental Retardation" and along with her other stuff, that's her 'label.' its neither good nor bad. It gets her services. it gives the medical professionals a common language. It only stings when you hear it on the street said in a derogatory way... it just is one more way we 'dehumanize' a group of people we see as not having as much value... same as all the other slang out there.
Good lord, I've written the world's longest comment! Im so sorry! i guess your post got to me :)
was 'Aspie' created by people with Asperger's or someone else? I've only ever heard it from people with Asperger's, or from someone quoting someone with Asperger's.
That said, I don't like Intellectual disability either.
There are two kinds of 'Mental Retardation.' 'Cognitive Retardation' and 'Functional Retardation.' The only one of the two you can truly measure is 'Functional.' How about 'Functionally Disabled?' That would be more accurate, at least for my son. He is not potty trained, doesn't talk, is only starting to feed himself... There's a lot he can do, but he really needs one on one help to function, and be safe.
I think during one discussion about "Aspie", someone pulled an ancient email out of their archive - the oldest one using the term and it was by an NT. But my memory isn't perfect and I haven't be able to find the discussion.
Hi, Navi.
In the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (recent edition), cognitive delays/disorders are also learning disabilities (or specific learning difficulties in much of the Commonwealth of Nations - general in the specifically British usage) and sometimes they are called dementia - if they happen to people above 18 years of age. Chris Borthwick writes about this, and the implications. (I think you might have a bit of a laugh at the Borges list, or one quite similar in Mad Bad and Sad, which had the causes of the disorders of the women circa 1800).
When we talk about functional limitations, they are not tied to any particular diagnosis of impairment or handicap. They are in "major life activities", as you say in the Americans with Disabilities Act.
Alicia, I would probably know about your daughter that her measured IQ is about 35-50 (the cognitive impairment: this is relative). And it may or may not be consistent in one or two areas. Or it would be >20 (because profound would be <20: unless she happened to be 'untestable').
Can certainly appreciate this is a vexed issue! And wonder what some of us are doing with our own intelligence (in all areas).
I would have assumed that functional impairment = "deficits in adaptive behaviour"?
I rather suspect that Aspie is one of St Tony's coinages, I am not bothered by it myself, but I am bothered by the use of disabled other than in the social model context as it creates confusion even more than impairment does,
Intellectually or cognitively impaired would be a better term.
I don't mind being referred to as cognitively impaired, because relative to the norm I am, certain places my brain just will not go.
I wish we could reclaim retarded in the original sense that is to say nothing to do with intellectual impairment, but as an adjective for anything that is late or delayed, such as a bus or a train "en retard, comme disent les Francais"
If for instance I am late for an appointment I could say grammatically that I was retarded by a points failure at Clapham junction or whatever.
I am with you Marla, I hate the word retard. I always have and I get very upset when I hear the kids at school using it (give explanation why), don't allow my girls to use it, but what upsets me more is when adults use it. I was listening to a radio show, and it had Martha Stewart's daughter, Alexis, hosting and she must have used the word retard (her show is on radio called Whatever) 50 times. I e-mailed her directly about how insulting and hurtful that was, never got a response, but she still does it. I just don't listen anymore. She by far is not the only one! Adults seem just as bad in the entertainment world, and I think it is horrible.
I usually try to e-mail if I hear it, but I doubt it does much good. At least I feel I'm taking some action.
As far as educating the kids I work with, I feel better, more hopeful there.
By the way, the word crazy, upsets me, for obvious reasons.
Excellent post, my friend.
XOXOX
I was attacked by people who think the "R" word is funny
Personally, I like to take the "dis" out of disabilities and then I can focus on the "abilities"
We all are born with different "abilities" or experience a change in our abilities as a result of life-changing events.
Yes, I know that we need the label for the services needed to help individuals and families... but let's leave it at that... we are so not a label...
I for one remember the adovcate you were demonstrated, even in grade school, "You had a no tolerance approach to how people treated your sister." You stood in the gap and created a "no tolerance zone" of those who displayed their ignorance and insensitivity. You amazed me then and you still do to this day.
This so true..to be able to treat all as humans it takes a lot.Good article here.
medical call center
Post a Comment